AI, copyright and music ownership: what the current legal landscape means for songwriters
Courts in the US and UK are beginning to rule on whether AI-generated music can be copyrighted and whether training on copyrighted material constitutes infringement. We explain the key cases and what they mean for human songwriters.
Courts in the United States and United Kingdom are beginning to rule on whether AI-generated music can receive copyright protection and whether training large language and audio models on copyrighted recordings constitutes infringement. For human songwriters and recording artists, these cases will shape the legal landscape of music creation for decades. Here is a plain account of where the law currently stands and what it means in practice.
Can AI-generated music be copyrighted?
In the US, the Copyright Office has stated clearly that copyright protection requires human authorship. Works generated entirely by AI without human creative input are not eligible for copyright registration. The Thaler v. Perlmutter case (2023) established this principle directly, with the court ruling that a work generated solely by an autonomous computer system is not copyrightable. The practical implication: if you prompt an AI to generate a full piece of music and make no further creative choices, you may not own copyright in the result. However, AI-assisted works — where a human makes meaningful creative decisions in selecting, arranging or transforming AI output — may be eligible for protection in the human-authored elements. The US Copyright Office issued guidance in 2023 clarifying this distinction (copyright.gov).
Training data and the infringement question
Several major lawsuits are active against AI music companies (Suno and Udio among them) and against AI image and text generators that used copyrighted material in training datasets. The Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA) and several major labels filed suits in 2024 alleging that training AI models on copyrighted recordings without a licence constitutes infringement of the reproduction right. These cases are ongoing as of 2026, with no definitive ruling at the appellate level. UK law has a specific "text and data mining" exception for non-commercial research; commercial AI training falls outside it. The EU AI Act, which entered into force in 2024, requires AI providers to disclose which copyrighted works were used in training. Music Business Worldwide (musicbusinessworldwide.com) covers new developments in these cases regularly.
What independent artists and songwriters should do
Until these legal questions are resolved, several practical steps protect independent artists. Register compositions with a PRO (PRS, ASCAP, BMI) and master recordings with a neighbouring rights collector (PPL, SoundExchange). Register any original recordings you want to protect with the relevant copyright authority (copyright.gov in the US). If using AI tools in your production or songwriting, document the human creative decisions you make — selection, editing, arrangement — to support a copyright claim in the human-authored elements. Avoid uploading unpublished masters to AI platforms that train on user submissions without clear opt-out options. Review terms of service before using any AI music tool.
Frequently asked questions
Not necessarily. If you use AI as a tool — like you use a synthesiser or a plugin — and make meaningful creative choices about what the AI generates, the human-authored elements of the result may be copyrightable. What matters is whether a human made sufficiently creative decisions. Documenting those decisions strengthens any future claim. Our guide on copyright basics covers what copyright protects.
This is the central question of current litigation. In most jurisdictions, the legal answer is not yet settled. The practical answer: review the terms of service of any platform where you upload music. Some platforms include training rights in their terms; others explicitly exclude them. Opt-out options, where they exist, should be exercised if you do not consent to your music being used for AI training.
Music Business Worldwide (musicbusinessworldwide.com) covers AI music litigation in detail. The US Copyright Office publishes guidance and decisions at copyright.gov. The Featured Artists Coalition (featuredartists.com) and the Musicians' Union (musiciansunion.org.uk) in the UK both publish policy positions and updates on AI and musicians' rights.